- What is a liquidity network?
- Who owns a liquidity network?
- How does trading begin?
- Is that all the new money will do? Go out from the council and come back again?
- Why would council workers agree to take part of their wages in the new money?
- Why bother with bonuses ? Why not just let people decide whether they want to accept quid or not?
- What happens if the amount of trading in the network shrinks rather than grows?
- What happens if the network doesn't work?
- What happens if a business goes bust?
- Who provides the knowhow and software?
- Who is Feasta?
- Every currency can be changed into another currency. Can I buy or sell quid with euros?
- Who will pay for the work needed to start a network?
- What is involved in starting a liquidity network?
- Is there a trial period?
- Does VAT or tax have to be paid on transactions doen in quid?
- Can you take out a loan from the network?
- Why would local shops accept payment in quid?
- We already have a paper currency in our town. Can we use this as a stepping stone to a liquidity network?
- Is the technology a barrier for smaller communities who want to adopt such a system? What about a town of 1000 people for example?
- Is the quid backed by anything?
- What if I don't do much business with the council but want to get involved? How can I earn quid?
- How is a liquidity network different from local paper currencies, such as the Lewes Pound?
- How will a network benefit the participating councils?
- How will the network benefit local Businesses?
- How will it benefit the Community?
- How does one business pay another business?
- How can I pay for a newspaper?
- How do I pay my motor tax?
- How do I find out more?
- How does a Liquidity Network differ from a paper currency?
- How does a Liquidity Network differ from gift vouchers?
1 - Notification of when your question has been answered. (Optional)
-
What is a liquidity network?
A system for creating and managing local electronic trading currencies in a way that encourages local trading and improves cashflow.
-
Who owns a liquidity network?
Ownership is vested in a trust set up to run the network in the interests of all the users. Thus a network is not owned by the users but by a body which they collectively control. This arrangement is designed to prevent the users of a network deciding at some point in the future to sell it out to a commercial company, such as a bank, for their personal profit in the way that many building societies were demutualised in Britain. The intention is that a liquidity network should become a community asset. As local authorities and local traders are key participants in any liquidity network, they have to be represented on the controlling trust.
-
How does trading begin?
Quids (each network will have their own name for the currency units) are initially created by the local council, who issue them to staff and contracts as a small part of their wages or fees. The Quids are effectively IOUs because the council must accept them in payment for rates, water charges or car taxes.
In the trial phase of the network, the council must accept back the full amount that has been issued. If the network proves successful and moves to the full version of the system the trust will decide how much the council must accept of what period of time.
The trust discusses with each participating local authority how much of their costs they can pay in the network's unit, the quid, in the first year, and how much they should be able to take back in payment of local charges, rates and so on. It then decides how big an advance on their future bonuses it can give them.
These bonuses are payments for helping to develop the system. Council staff will have to spend time adjusting their accounting systems to handle both quid and euros, and getting the agreement of contractors, suppliers and workers to take part-payment in quid. The bonuses the councils receive are paid according to their degree of success.
-
Is that all the new money will do? Go out from the council and come back again?
The system is designed so that other spending circuits develop too. Businesses don't earn bonuses for the quid payments they make to the councils. For their bonuses, they need to persuade their staff and suppliers to accept quid payments too. They get lots of other people in the community involved. That's the way the network builds the local economy.
-
Why would council workers agree to take part of their wages in the new money?
There's both a stick and a carrot. The stick is that the workers know that, because their council's income has been cut by the current crisis, they may have to work shorter hours or even be laid off if they don't accept some quid. The carrot is that they know that they will get a bonus in quid if they do. And, of course, they know that most local shops will accept the new money.
-
Why bother with bonuses ? Why not just let people decide whether they want to accept quid or not?
Everyone would prefer to be paid in euros if they had a free choice because quid will only be accepted locally while euros are accepted everywhere. So the bonuses are a necessary incentive to people to use the liquidity network. But the bonuses are not something for nothing. They are paid, for example, to someone who is trading with more and more people, or if the amount of trading they are doing in in quid is going up and up. These people are helping build the system up and if, thanks to them, the network's total turnover is growing, more quid will need to be injected into the system to lubricate the expanding trade and it is right that at least some of the new money should be put into use by being given to those who made the injection necessary.
-
What happens if the amount of trading in the network shrinks rather than grows?
If trade in a network turned down, it would be necessary to remove quid from circulation to ensure that they kept their value.
There are two ways of removing quids. Those taken back by the council in payment for rates etc. are not put back into circulation or fees are applied to those people who are hording quids.
The network's software sends out warnings to the people with the slowest accounts - those that were being used least relative to the balance in them - telling them that a proportion of their previous bonuses would be withdrawn in a few weeks' time unless their trading increased. Each month the decline went on, more quid would be taken out of the system than was being injected into the most active accounts at the top. However, no accountholder would ever lose more units than they had been given as bonuses in the past. Quid that people had earned by working or trading would never be taken away.
-
What happens if the network doesn't work?
As all the quid in a system would have been given to one accountholder or another, the withdrawals would continue until no units were left and the system could be wound up. All the effort that people put into gettting it started would have been wasted, but no-one would end up in debt or having lost money.
-
What happens if a business goes bust?
The account will form part of the assets of the company in the same way that euro bank accounts will. From the business accounts perspective, all invoices are raised in euros, but some are paid, or part paid in Quids, so the liquidation process will be the same.
-
Who provides the knowhow and software?
The software required to run a network is being developed by Feasta, a non-profit economic thinktank and the rights to it will be transfered to a non-profit umbrella body, UB, which will be set up to provide common services to all the liquidity networks in the country. The UB will license the use of the software to member networks subject to the payment of an annual fee to support its activities. Besides software, the UB will provide networks with legal advice, political and media support, and help with selecting the best technologies. The directors of the UB will all be chosen by member networks.
-
Who is Feasta?
Feasta is a not-for-profit thinktank on sustainable economics. The position Feasta has adopted is that many of the world's problems are caused not by bad people but by dysfunctional systems and it sees its purpose as designing better systems. Current projects include development of a local electronic trading currency, assessment of carbon sources and sinks in ireland and a smart tax system. For more information see http://feasta.org
-
Every currency can be changed into another currency. Can I buy or sell quid with euros?
Yes, from traders and other individuals. But the trust itself will never buy or sell quid for other currencies or recognise any exchange rate between them. If it did it would be in breach of the law.
-
Who will pay for the work needed to start a network?
As a network is not going to be run to make a profit for investors, it cannot be financed in the conventional way. So, if sponsors cannot be found to pay the upfront costs, the people who expect to benefit from its operation need to be prepared to put some conventional money into developing it themselves. They should put in the seed money on the understanding that they will get it back in the system's own units once trading begins.
Alternative, national and EU funding may also be an option.
Once a network is running, accountholders will have to pay a monthly fee to the trust to cover its running costs, just as they do to their bank.
-
What is involved in starting a liquidity network?
A money system will not work well unless it has critical mass. A lot of organisations, businesses and people need to be prepared to accept the new money from Day One. To ensure this, it is essential that an area's local authorities and trading organisations such as the chambers of commerce get involved at the planning stage. They each need to nominate someone to work part-time on the planning committee.At least one full-time worker is going to be needed for about three months as well, in addition to lots of volunteers.
-
Is there a trial period?
Yes. The initial trial phase lasts 3-12 months and has some limited functionality and during this period the council must accept back all the quids they issued, ie. the currency is fully backed by the council. Once the network is deemed to be a success, the live phase can be implemented where additional currency can be added to the system but the council can offset it's bonuses against issued currency and there is no longer responsible for the all the issued currency. The trust will make the decision when and if to move from the trial to full network.
-
Does VAT or tax have to be paid on transactions doen in quid?
Yes. And it will have to be paid in euros until central government agrees to take payment in quid.
-
Can you take out a loan from the network?
No. A liquidity network is purely for buying and selling and not for saving or borrowing. The whole point is to get away from debt.
-
Why would local shops accept payment in quid?
The network aims to make transactions using quids cheaper then transaction using euros by charging less than banks and credit card companies.
Businesses will also be eligible to earn discounts and bonuses to further reduce the costs of doing businesses.
The network offers discounts for early payment of invoices in quids encouraging improved cashflow for businesses.
The network infrastructure also makes it easy to add online shops, loyalty schemes and other methods for improving sales. -
We already have a paper currency in our town. Can we use this as a stepping stone to a liquidity network?
Yes, but if your paper currency's value is linked to the euro, the link has to be switched to the quid instead.
-
Is the technology a barrier for smaller communities who want to adopt such a system? What about a town of 1000 people for example?
Is the technology a barrier for smaller communities who want to adopt such a system? What about a town of 1000 people for example?
The system uses equipment - mobile phones and netbook computers - that are cheap and a lot of people have anyway. So, if a small community wants to start a system, its size is no barrier. However, a local authority does need to be involved and those planning the start-up should remember that the more people who use a currency, the more valuable it is. Could they link with the community next door?
-
Is the quid backed by anything?
In the early stages, it is backed by the willingness of the local councils to accept it as equivalent to the euro. However, once the councils have earned enough bonuses to cover their advances, they don't have to accept quid at all. Their backing can be removed. From then on, it's up to the other users to back it by accepting it for their goods and services.
-
What if I don't do much business with the council but want to get involved? How can I earn quid?
Advertise for business on the network's website and in the local paper.
-
How is a liquidity network different from local paper currencies, such as the Lewes Pound?
Lots of community currencies have been set up in the past. What's different about a liquidity network is that, because it is electronic, the number of quid in circulation can be fine-tuned. The technology for doing that has not been available before. No previous currency system has had the ability to give extra units to users who are expanding the system and take previous bonuses away from those who don't need them because they are not trading actively enough.
-
How will a network benefit the participating councils?
During the period a network is expanding, a lot of the new money required to finance the increased volume of trade will enter circulation by being given as bonuses to the councils. This will enable them to provide services to the community without having to raise the money locally in the conventional way or get it from central government.
During the start-up phase, there is a risk that a network might fail to take off and that the trust will have to ask the councils to return the quid they were allowed to spend into circulation as an advance on the bonuses they were expected to be able to earn. If that happens, the councils will have to borrow euros to replace the quid that come back to them in service charges which they have to transfer back to the trust. So the worst possible outcome for the council is that the advance the trust gives it turns out to be an interest-free loan rather than the grant it would have become if the network had taken off.
-
How will the network benefit local Businesses?
Additional currency will be available to spend locally.
Business who spend their Quids widely and help to grow the network, will be rewarded with bonuses.
Discounts will be given to businesses who pay their invoices early and this discount will be paid by the network, so the supplier gets the full value.
1. The cost of transactions using Quids will be less than credit cards or banking charges, and if the network is successful, transaction costs can be reduced further by discounts and bonuses.
2. Because the transactions happen online, adding an online shop will be easy and cheap to do.
3. Other options, including loyalty schemes, special promotions etc. can be added easily. -
How will it benefit the Community?
All users of the network can earn bonuses for supporting and growing the network, so using Quids to pay for local purchases can earn discounts and bonuses.
There is an option for any bonuses to be awarded to a charity of your choice. -
How does one business pay another business?
An online accounting and banking system is available to make it easier than in euros to pay other businesses that operate with Quids. All invoice information is sent through from the supplier, no need to enter it onto each businesses accounting system. No need to request statements or copy invoices, they are all available online whenever they are needed. You can even setup the system to automatically pay invoices as soon as you approve them and there is sufficient balance in your account, giving you the best chance of earning an early payment discount from the system.
-
How can I pay for a newspaper?
Once a local network's basic system has bedded down, the UB will give it the option of adding an electronic purse of its members' ID card or mobile phoine. This would enable them to pay for small items by passing their phone or card close to a pad at the shop till. The London Underground and the Dublin LUAS use this system already.
-
How do I pay my motor tax?
You can pay part or all of your motor tax (rates and water charges) with Quids. Simply substitute Quids on a 1 for 1 basis with Euros.
-
How do I find out more?
Send us an email at info@feasta.org
-
How does a Liquidity Network differ from a paper currency?
A paper currency is an open system. Once the currency is issued the is no control or record as to where the currency travels. The Liquidity Network is a closed system so every transaction is recorded on the system and so it is possible to see how the system is being used and manage the flow of currency. It is not possible to withdraw currency from a closed system, for example, in the form of a paper note, it is only possible to spend it away. This has two major advantages. It makes fraud much more difficult because to use the currency you must have registered on the system and all transactions are recorded on the system. The second advantage is that should there be a 'run on the bank', currency cannot with withdrawn so if you think the currency is losing value all you can do is spend it, and by spending it help to support the currency.
For traders, paper money creates additional work to record transactions and hold change, so there are downsides for local traders to want to handle the currency in the long term. With a purely electronic currency in a closed system, the transactions are automatically recorded, there is no need for change and the cost of transacting in the local currency can be less than in euros. This gives local traders direct benefits and will incentivise them to use the currency widely.
-
How does a Liquidity Network differ from gift vouchers?
Unlike gift vouchers schemes, Linden dollars or many paper currencies, there is no exchange with euro/dollars. You cannot buy "quids" you can only earn them. The currency is created and removed by the initiating sponsor, in most cases a local council. They are allowed to issue a certain amount of currency, effectively IOUs, which they can use to pay staff or sub-contractors, on condition that they accept the currency back in payment for rates, taxes and charges.
1 - Notification of when your question has been answered. (Optional)